Why Fitzpatrick Is Right About Cynthia Pugh
The murder of suburban businessman James Pipines by his scorned mistress-slash-bookeeper Cynthia Pugh happened back in the 1970's--but is still exciting Central NY gossips and scandal-mongers to this day.
Back at the time of the trial, with absolutely no evidence pointing to anyone other than Ms. Pugh, many people were convinced she was railroaded--largely because they were mad that Mr. Pipines had the gall to simultaneously break off the affair and fire Ms. Pugh.
Today, the district attorney who prosecuted the case is now the head D.A. and has worked to keep Ms. Pugh from receiving parole, largely because he considers her to be unrepentant.
I generally do not support Mr. Fitzpatrick, a rather in-your-face conservative with a holier-than-thou attitude and a bit of the bully about him. However, he is absolutely correct in this case.
In a NY Times review of his new book on the history of trials, English trial attorney Sadakat Kadri is quoted: "The trial has always operated to rebalance communities after someone has broken the rules, and whether it has allowed suspects back into the fold or expelled them from it, it has demanded that they make their acceptance of those rules manifest through humility or remorse."
Back at the time of the trial, with absolutely no evidence pointing to anyone other than Ms. Pugh, many people were convinced she was railroaded--largely because they were mad that Mr. Pipines had the gall to simultaneously break off the affair and fire Ms. Pugh.
Today, the district attorney who prosecuted the case is now the head D.A. and has worked to keep Ms. Pugh from receiving parole, largely because he considers her to be unrepentant.
I generally do not support Mr. Fitzpatrick, a rather in-your-face conservative with a holier-than-thou attitude and a bit of the bully about him. However, he is absolutely correct in this case.
In a NY Times review of his new book on the history of trials, English trial attorney Sadakat Kadri is quoted: "The trial has always operated to rebalance communities after someone has broken the rules, and whether it has allowed suspects back into the fold or expelled them from it, it has demanded that they make their acceptance of those rules manifest through humility or remorse."